Ari Horesh's profile picture on EnterMedSchool

Are you an aspiring medical student torn between the International Medical Admissions Test (IMAT) and the Medical College Admission Test (MCAT)? These exams, essential for admission to prestigious medical programs in Italy and North America respectively, can pose a dilemma for many hopefuls. In this blog post, we’ll dive deep into each exam’s format, content, and difficulty level while providing useful preparation strategies to succeed. Curious about which test is harder? Keep reading as we demystify both tests and help you make a well-informed decision!

All medical schools in Italy in English that accept IMAT
All medical schools in Italy in English that accept IMAT

Understanding The IMAT And MCAT

The IMAT and MCAT are both entrance exams that aspiring medical students must take, with the former being required for admission to Italian medical schools while the latter is taken by those seeking admission to medical schools in the United States, Canada, and Australia.

Overview Of Each Exam

The International Medical Admissions Test (IMAT) is a popular entrance exam designed specifically for international students who wish to apply for Medicine or Dentistry courses at leading Italian medical schools that have courses in English. This examination assesses a candidate’s skills in logical reasoning, problem-solving, and scientific aptitude across Biology, Chemistry, Physics, and Mathematics. It consists of 60 multiple-choice questions with a maximum duration of 100 minutes to complete the test.

On the other hand, the Medical College Admission Test (MCAT) is a standardized computer-based test widely recognized in the United States and Canada as an essential component of most medical school applications. The MCAT aims to evaluate applicant knowledge in physical sciences, biological sciences, social sciences as well as verbal reasoning abilities typically required for succeeding in rigorous medical curricula.

Essentially consisting of four sections: Chemical and Physical Foundations of Biological Systems; Critical Analysis and Reasoning Skills; Biological and Biochemical Foundations of Living Systems; and Psychological, Social, and Biological Foundations of Behavior. The MCAT test-takers have approximately 7 hours to complete this comprehensive exam.

The MCAT exam is much harder than the IMAT. It is way more competitive, there are less avaialble seats, and the syllabus is much broader.

Both exams present unique challenges due to their distinct focus areas within medical education; however, it’s crucial for aspiring physicians from around the globe aiming towards successful admissions into reputable institutions not only study diligently but also familiarize themselves with each respective exam format thoroughly prior venturing onto these high-stakes tests.

Difficulty Level Comparison Of The IMAT And MCAT

This section of the article will compare and analyze the difficulty level of the IMAT and MCAT exams, taking into account various factors that affect exam complexity such as opinions from medical students and experts, average scores, and content differences.

Factors That Affect Difficulty Level

There are several factors that can affect the difficulty level of the IMAT and MCAT exams. As an IMAT candidate, it is important to consider these factors when preparing for the exam:

  • Cognitive ability: The IMAT and MCAT are both aptitude tests that measure cognitive abilities such as critical thinking, problem-solving, and analytical skills. Therefore, candidates with a higher cognitive ability may find it easier to perform well on these exams.
  • Academic rigor: Medical school admissions committees often consider the academic rigor of a candidate’s undergraduate program when evaluating their application. This means that candidates who attended schools with a more rigorous curriculum may have an easier time with the exam.
  • Test-taking strategies: Candidates who have developed effective test-taking strategies may find it easier to navigate the structure of the exam and manage their time efficiently.
  • Test anxiety: Some candidates may experience test anxiety, which can impact their performance on the exam. Effective stress management techniques can help to alleviate this anxiety.
  • Exam preparation courses: Taking preparation courses specifically designed for the IMAT or MCAT can provide candidates with valuable study materials, practice tests, feedback from instructors, and test-taking strategies to improve performance on the exam.
  • Study materials: Adequate preparation for either exam requires access to high-quality study materials such as past papers and preparation books tailored to each respective test.
  • Exam formats: The format of each exam can also play a role in its perceived difficulty level. For example, while both exams require extensive knowledge in science subjects, the IMAT requires additional knowledge in general knowledge subjects such as logic and math.

Ultimately, regardless of which exam you choose to take as an aspiring medical student, adequate preparation including effective study habits and expert sources of guidance is key to successful performance on standardized tests like these ones!

Opinions From Medical Students And Experts

When it comes to the difficulty level of the IMAT and MCAT, the main claim that the MCAT’s intense focus on natural sciences makes it much harder then the IMAT exam, particularly given the exam’s length and complexity.

Regardless of which exam they perceived as harder, many agree that both exams require significant preparation time and a strong foundation in scientific aptitude. On top of this, test-taking strategies such as time management and problem-solving skills are crucial for success on both tests.

Ultimately, it is important for prospective medical students to consider their individual strengths and weaknesses when deciding between these two exams. While one may be more suited towards analytical reasoning while another has stronger science knowledge retention capabilities – adequate preparation is key regardless of personal preferences or tendencies for either exam.

Comparison Of Average Scores

When comparing average scores of the IMAT and MCAT exams, it’s essential to keep in mind that different grading systems are used for each test. To make a fair comparison, let’s look at the average scores and the maximum achievable scores of each exam.

ExamAverage ScoreMaximum Achievable Score
IMAT30.0 (not enough to pass)90.0

The IMAT has a maximum achievable score of 90, with an average score of 30, whereas the MCAT has a maximum achievable score of 528 with an average score of approximately 500. Please note that comparing these scores directly may not accurately reflect the difficulty level of each exam since they are designed differently and assess different subjects. However, these average scores can be used as a gauge to understand how well candidates typically perform on each test based on the percentile of people who pass the exam.

Final Thoughts: Which One Is Harder, The IMAT Or The MCAT?

After examining the differences and similarities between the two exams, it ultimately comes down to personal preference and individual strengths when deciding which one is harder, the IMAT or the MCAT.

Summary Of The Key Differences And Similarities

When it comes to the IMAT and MCAT, there are key differences in format and content that set these exams apart. While both tests measure scientific knowledge, critical thinking skills, problem-solving abilities, and reading comprehension, the MCAT also includes verbal reasoning and quantitative reasoning sections. The IMAT focuses more on specific scientific areas like biology, chemistry, physics as well as general knowledge and logical reasoning.

Another important similarity is the importance of adequate preparation for both exams. Both require strong time management skills along with effective test-taking strategies to maximize performance. This means developing good study habits early on, utilizing reliable study resources such as books or online guidance websites which cover every aspect of the exam.

Ultimately, candidates should consider their strengths and weaknesses when deciding which test to take for admissions into medical school. It’s important not only to aim for high scores but also to factor in timing, retake policies if necessary (in case they do not achieve desired scores)and any other stipulated admission criteria specified by the institution where one intends applying at .

Factors To Consider When Deciding Which Exam To Take

When deciding between the IMAT and MCAT, there are several factors to keep in mind. One important consideration is your future medical school plans – if you hope to study medicine in Italy, then taking the IMAT may be necessary. Additionally, if you are an international student whose first language is not English the IMAT might be a better fit.

Another factor to consider when deciding which exam to take is your strengths and weaknesses as a test-taker. The MCAT tends to focus heavily on critical thinking and problem-solving skills, whereas the IMAT has more of a focus on science knowledge. Consider which type of test format plays more toward your areas of expertise and where you might need extra preparation. Ultimately whichever exam you choose, it’s important to ensure that you’re adequately prepared by utilizing resources such as question banks, past papers, preparation books for both exams before sitting for either one.

Ultimately, The Importance Of Adequate Preparation For Both Exams.

It cannot be overstated how crucial it is to adequately prepare for the IMAT and MCAT exams. These standardized tests are vital for admission into medical schools, and poor performance can drastically affect one’s chances of getting accepted. To succeed in these exams, candidates must utilize effective study resources and techniques, practice time management strategies, and avoid common mistakes that could prove costly on test day. By studying in the right direction and committing adequate focus and concentration to exam preparation, IMAT candidates can improve their learning outcomes and achieve academic success.

One effective method for preparing adequately for both exams is by utilizing study materials such as past papers or practice tests. This helps familiarize candidates with the format of the test questions while also testing their knowledge of key concepts they will encounter during the actual test. Effective learning strategies such as building good study habits like consistency in studying every day can help prevent a last-minute rush when cramming all information needed on short notice before an exam date arrives which often leads to less than optimal results. Ultimately, proper preparation is key to success in both the IMAT and MCAT exams – take advantage of available resources early-on so you have enough time to perfect your skills before exam day arrives!


In conclusion, both the IMAT and MCAT are challenging entrance exams that require adequate preparation to pass. While the IMAT focuses on science, the MCAT covers a broader range of topics including biology, chemistry, psychology, and critical analysis, spans 7 hours, and is more competitive than the IMAT. Our final conclusion is that the IMAT is easier than the MCAT.